Cover of Seeing Like a State

Book · 1998 · Central planning

Seeing Like a State

by James C. Scott · Recommended by 8 people on 8 podcasts

mentions
16
people
8
podcasts
8
episodes
12
recommendations
4

We earn a commission if you buy through the store links below, at no cost to you.

Seeing Like a State is just a fantastically book.
Tobi Lütke · Conversations with Tyler · Sep 2024 Listen at 59:53

What they say about it

Grouped from 16 mentions
  • Discusses state legibility“make taxpayers legible”
    3

The best things said about it

6 of 16 · every mention
Recommended
I keep going back to um James Scott, Seeing Like a State, which is, you know, an amazing book. If people haven't read it, absolutely pick up a copy.
On the show Behind the Bastards · Jan 2023
Recommended
If you're really interested in how infrastructure has the capacity to control and truly just how states sort of see things, I have to of course recommend the classic Jamesc.
Andrew Sage Behind the Bastards · Aug 2025
Recommended
I just want to recommend this this book that Elan and mock but actually recommend it to me so I'm just totally jacking from them that I I came to love it more than they ever will it's called seeing like a state by Jim Scott.
On the show a16z Podcast · Jan 2019
Critiqued
I think that James C. Scott's most popular work, Seeing Like a State, is also, unfortunately, his, I would say, weakest work.
Dan Wang Conversations with Tyler · Dec 2025
Discussed
His best known work is Seeing Like a State in which Scott wrote about how the state really tries to organize the population in order.
Dan Wang Freakonomics Radio · Sep 2025
Discussed
One of the main aims of the state, and this is from the book, Seeing Like a State, he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible.
Robert Breedlove The Rubin Report · Jul 2024

Where and when it comes up

Mentions per year

Counted mentions by episode date. Our archive is deeper for recent years.

How it comes up

Recommended means the speaker tells listeners to read it.

Most mentions, by podcast

8 shows

8 people who brought it up

Most recommendations first

Why people recommend it

James C. Scott's Seeing Like a State is a political science study examining how large-scale state planning and administrative projects often fail by ignoring local conditions. Andrew Sage recommended the book on Behind the Bastards for those interested in state control and infrastructure, though he later critiqued the author's characterization of Esperanto. Tobi Lütke praised the work on Conversations with Tyler as a fantastic and irreplaceable text following the author's passing. Tom and Ilan Zechory also recommended the book on Behind the Bastards and the a16z Podcast, respectively, highlighting its insights into how states and organizations manage space and prioritize incremental work. Conversely, Dan Wang offered a critique on Conversations with Tyler, viewing it as the author's weakest work, while also citing the text on Freakonomics Radio to explain how mountains offer refuge from state authority. Ezra Klein referenced the book on The Ezra Klein Show to discuss how states and modern algorithms require legible systems to function.

Every mention

16 counted mentions
Andrew Sage If you're really interested in how infrastructure has the capacity to control and truly just how states sor… 3
Recommended
“If you're really interested in how infrastructure has the capacity to control and truly just how states sort of see things, I have to of course recommend the classic Jamesc.”
Critiqued
“And here's where I think James C. Scott had a rather negative characterization of Espiranto as a purely high modernist endeavor as though all Espiranes sought to make Espiranto the official international language. In seem like a state, he claims that Espiranto was created to replace the dialects and vernaculars of Europe.”
Critiqued
“When I saw that I remember reading seem like a state some years ago and I probably glossed over that but in doing the research for this I ended up you know stumbling upon it again and I was like after reading the history I was like this isn't quite accurate.”
Tobi Lütke I think as um most interes see seeing like a state is just a fantastically book I I he just passed away you… 1
Recommended
“I think as um most interes see seeing like a state is just a fantastically book I I he just passed away you probably saw that on Twitter it's yes yesterday or so a couple days ago um yeah what a fantastic mind and like a I I know no um it is one of those books you read which”
Dan Wang I think that James C. Scott's most popular work, Seeing Like a State, is also, unfortunately, his, I would… 2
Critiqued
“I think that James C. Scott's most popular work, Seeing Like a State, is also, unfortunately, his, I would say, weakest work.”
Discussed
“Yeah, I was born in China's most mountainous province and I am still very much attracted to mountains in part because of the works of political scientist and anthropologist James C. Scott of Yale University. His best known work is seeing like a state in which Scott wrote about how the state really tries to organize the population in order”
Robert Breedlove so this is from the book uh seeing like a state he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible 2
Discussed
“so this is from the book uh seeing like a state he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible”
Discussed
“One of the main aims of the state, and this is from the book, seeing like a state, he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible.”
Andrew (Andrewism) You know, um James C. Scott talks about this in seeing like a state. You can't just the in these states the… 1
Discussed
“You know, um James C. Scott talks about this in seeing like a state. You can't just the in these states they they they start these sort of forestry projects. They they they try to legible legibleize you know these forests these simple rows”
Balaji Srinivasan in fact there's a book called seeing like a state which actually talks about the origins of surnames and wh… 1
Discussed
“in fact there's a book called seeing like a state which actually talks about the origins of surnames and whatnot”
Dwarkesh Patel Beijing's urban design looks like something straight out of James Scott's Seeing Like a State. 1
Discussed
“Beijing's urban design looks like something straight out of James Scott's Seeing Like a State.”
Ezra Klein You know the old book James Scott seeing like a state, right? That the state has to make things legible to… 1
Discussed
“You know the old book James Scott seeing like a state, right? That the state has to make things legible to itself.”
Mentioned on the show without a named speaker4
Recommended
“I keep going back to um James Scott, Seeing Like a State, which is, you know, an amazing book. If people haven't read it, absolutely pick up a copy.”
Recommended
“I just want to recommend this this book that Elan and mock but actually recommend it to me so I'm just totally jacking from them that I I came to love it more than they ever will it's called seeing like a state by Jim Scott”
Discussed
“a thing in a sense like anything great is messy building anything great is messy and so if you look at like you know an art studio or an operating room or you know my favorite example just from seeing like the state”
Discussed
“the idiosyncrasies of your situation are more relevant than you think like you can't truly describe your whole situation in like an hour or something like it's you know a lot more use and credited stuff than you think”

Also mentioned in the same episodes

Portraits from Wikimedia Commons: Tobi Lütke, Union Eleven / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0); Ezra Klein, SWinxy / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0).