Book · 1887 · Action & Adventure Fiction
A Study in Scarlet
Why people recommend it
A Study in Scarlet by Arthur Conan Doyle is the foundational 1887 detective novel that introduced the legendary consulting detective Sherlock Holmes and his loyal companion Dr. John Watson. On The Book Review, Michael Sims discussed Arthur Conan Doyle's first Sherlock Holmes novel, noting that while it is a historic starting point, it is not necessarily the very best of the Holmes adventures. Sims reflected on the evolution of the iconic detective series, contextualizing the initial mystery within the broader scope of Doyle's legendary canon. Additionally, on No Stupid Questions, the fact-checker confirmed Stephen's reference to Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes novel, validating a literary passage read aloud during the program. The hosts explored the mechanics of memory and why readers forget large portions of what they read, using the classic detective story as a recognizable anchor for discussing narrative retention and literary comprehension. Both podcasts celebrated the enduring legacy of the famous sleuth while offering nuanced critiques of his earliest printed case. Through these engaging literary conversations, the novel remains firmly established as a cornerstone of detective fiction, inspiring generations of readers, writers, and scholars to explore the fascinating origins of modern forensic investigation and classic British mystery literature.
Who recommended it
- Michael Sims Discussed
Michael Sims — 1 mention
“and a study in Scarlet the first book Is Not the very best of the the Holmes Adventures”
Mentioned on the show without a named speaker — 1
“the passage is from the author's 1887 detective novel a study in Scarlet he writes”