Why people recommend it
Notes to John is a posthumous collection of personal writings by Joan Didion that offers intimate glimpses into her thoughts and life. On The Book Review podcast episode titled Our Book Critics on Their 2025 in Reading, which aired on December 12, 2025, Alexandra Jacobs discussed the volume among her favorite reads of the year. Jacobs remarked that the book completely captivated her, though she playfully debated whether it could even be accurately classified within the traditional memoir genre. She observed that the publication of the book generated significant pre-publication controversy and intense public discussion, noting that such literary debates always ignite her enthusiasm as a critic. The commentary highlighted the enduring fascination surrounding Didion's life and work, proving that anything bearing her name continues to command the attention of the literary establishment. Jacobs praised the book for its ability to generate compelling conversations and spark critical interest upon its arrival. By sharing her experience with the text, she underscored the unique appeal of Didion's posthumous output, inviting listeners to appreciate the nuanced and provocative nature of the notes compiled within the publication.
Who recommended it
- Alexandra Jacobs Recommended
Alexandra Jacobs — 1 mention
“Another memoir that captivated me, although I don't even know if it could correctly fit into the memoir category, is Joan Ddian's Notes to John because when this this book came out, this is the kind of book that lights me a fire when there's a controversy preceding its publication or around its publication”