Book · 2012 · History
Men Against Fire
The Problem of Battle Command
- mentions
- 2
- people
- 2
- podcasts
- 2
- episodes
- 2
- recommendations
- 0
It comes from a book s.l.a marshall's controversial book men against fire the problem of battle command.
The best things said about it
His name was SLA marshal he read a book about this men against fire and he discovered that the majority of the soldiers didn't shoot.
Why people recommend it
Men Against Fire by S. L. A. Marshall is a controversial military history and sociology book that examines combat behavior, command dynamics, and the psychological barriers soldiers face when firing weapons in battle. The book was discussed across multiple podcast platforms regarding the statistical realities of warfare. On Modern Wisdom, Rutger Bregman brought up Marshall's work to discuss human nature and combat statistics, noting the author's controversial discovery that the majority of soldiers during combat did not actually fire their weapons at the enemy. This startling statistic challenged conventional assumptions about inherent human aggression and military readiness. Similarly, on Timcast IRL, a super chat reader referenced Marshall's controversial book during a live broadcast to clarify and expand upon a prior conversation concerning whether soldiers actually shoot their weapons under fire. Across both appearances, speakers and guests utilized Marshall's research to debate the complexities of military command, the psychology of combatants, and the broader implications of violence in human societies. Despite ongoing debates regarding the absolute accuracy of Marshall's methodology, Men Against Fire remains a frequently cited text in discussions concerning military history and the behavioral realities of warfare.
Every mention
Rutger Bregman his name was SLA marshal he read a book about this men against fire and he discovered that the majority of… 1
“his name was SLA marshal he read a book about this men against fire and he discovered that the majority of the soldiers didn't shoot”
Tim Pool it comes from a book s.l.a marshall's controversial book men against fire the problem of battle command 1
“it comes from a book s.l.a marshall's controversial book men against fire the problem of battle command”
