Book · 1998 · Central planning
Seeing Like a State
Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott has been mentioned in 18 episodes across 11 podcasts (6 episodes recommend it and 12 episodes discuss it), through . Most frequently brought up by Patrick O'Shaughnessy (3 episodes), Andrew Sage (2 episodes) and Max Schoening (1 episode) on Behind the Bastards (4 episodes), Invest Like the Best (4 episodes) and Conversations with Tyler (2 episodes).
- episodes
- 18
- podcasts
- 11
- people
- 12
- episodes recommend it
- 6
Seeing Like a State is just a fantastically book.
Tobi Lütke · Conversations with Tyler · Sep 2024 Listen at 59:53 Questions about Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott
Who recommends Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott on podcasts?
Patrick O'Shaughnessy (1 episode), Andrew Sage (1 episode), Max Schoening (1 episode) and Tobi Lütke (1 episode) have recommended Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott on podcasts. In all, 12 people brought it up across 11 podcasts (4 people recommended it).
Which podcasts mention Seeing Like a State the most?
Behind the Bastards (4 episodes), Invest Like the Best (4 episodes), Conversations with Tyler (2 episodes), a16z Podcast (1 episode) and Dwarkesh Podcast (1 episode), among 11 podcasts in all.
Is Seeing Like a State recommended, or only discussed?
Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott was recommended in 6 episodes, discussed without a recommendation in 10 episodes, and critiqued in 2 episodes, as of 2026-10-21.
What do people say about Seeing Like a State?
Tobi Lütke on Conversations with Tyler (2024-09-18): "Seeing Like a State is just a fantastically book."
When was Seeing Like a State last mentioned on a podcast?
Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott was last discussed on The Pragmatic Engineer by Will Larson on 2026-10-21.
What they say about it
- Makes taxpayers legible“the state tries to make taxpayers legible”2
- Top-down versus bottom-up2
The best things said about it
Seeing Like a State, which is all about how states or governments or whatever, their entire function is making legibility among their population.
If you're really interested in how infrastructure has the capacity to control and truly just how states sort of see things, I have to of course recommend the classic Jamesc.
I keep going back to um James Scott, Seeing Like a State, which is, you know, an amazing book. If people haven't read it, absolutely pick up a copy.
I think it was Eugene, our friend Eugene that first gave me the Seeing Like a State book by James C. got of the of just the very abstract idea that uh top- down systems just don't work as well over the very long term as bottom-up ones do.
One of the main aims of the state, and this is from the book Seeing Like a State, he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible.
There's a book called Seeing Like a State which actually talks about the origins of surnames and whatnot.
Where and when it comes up
How it comes up
12 people who brought it up
- Patrick O'Shaughnessy3 episodes · recommended in 1
- Andrew Sage2 episodes · recommended in 1
- Max Schoening1 episode · recommended in 1
Tobi Lütke1 episode · recommended in 1- Dan Wang2 episodes
- Andrew (Andrewism)1 episode
- Balaji Srinivasan1 episode
- Dwarkesh Patel1 episode
Ezra Klein1 episode- Michael Mayer1 episode
- Robert Breedlove1 episode
- Will Larson1 episode
Why people recommend it
Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott is a profound examination of how large-scale state projects and centralized planning often fail by ignoring local conditions and human complexity. Max Schoening recommended the book on Lenny's Podcast to executives designing organizational systems, pointing out its insights into the limits of legibility, while Patrick O'Shaughnessy similarly praised it on Invest Like the Best for highlighting the importance of grassroots local knowledge. On Behind the Bastards, Andrew Sage and the host both urged listeners to pick up the classic text to understand how large infrastructure projects enable social control. Tobi Lütke also championed the book on Conversations with Tyler, calling it a fantastic and irreplaceable work by a brilliant mind. Meanwhile, Will Larson noted on The Pragmatic Engineer that familiarity with the text is practically a staple in Silicon Valley for understanding bureaucratic perspectives, even though Dan Wang offered a dissenting critique on Conversations with Tyler by calling it Scott's weakest work.
Every mention
Patrick O'Shaughnessy Have you ever read the book Seeing Like a State by George Scott? No. You should definitely check it out. So… 3
“I think it was Eugene, our friend Eugene that first gave me the Seeing Like a State book by James C. got of the of just the very abstract idea that uh top- down systems just don't work as well over the very long term as bottom-up ones do.”
“It reminds me of that amazing, what's the author's name, James Scott or something, that's seeing like a state book. 100%. My memory of that book is the top-down desire to make something understandable perverts the thing.”
“Have you ever read the book Seeing Like a State by George Scott? No. You should definitely check it out. So it's all about this concept of, I think it's a Greek term, metis, which is local knowledge.”
Andrew Sage If you're really interested in how infrastructure has the capacity to control and truly just how states sor… 2
“If you're really interested in how infrastructure has the capacity to control and truly just how states sort of see things, I have to of course recommend the classic Jamesc.”
“And here's where I think James C. Scott had a rather negative characterization of Espiranto as a purely high modernist endeavor as though all Espiranes sought to make Espiranto the official international language. In seem like a state, he claims that Espiranto was created to replace the dialects and vernaculars of Europe.”
“When I saw that I remember reading seem like a state some years ago and I probably glossed over that but in doing the research for this I ended up you know stumbling upon it again and I was like after reading the history I was like this isn't quite accurate.”
Max Schoening And then the last one that I give mostly to executives uh that I think are creating a lot of systems uh is… 1
“And then the last one that I give mostly to executives uh that I think are creating a lot of systems uh is uh seeing like a state uh which I think there is a famous stack overflow that sort of um popularized this”
Tobi Lütke I think as um most interes see seeing like a state is just a fantastically book I I he just passed away you… 1
“I think as um most interes see seeing like a state is just a fantastically book I I he just passed away you probably saw that on Twitter it's yes yesterday or so a couple days ago um yeah what a fantastic mind and like a I I know no um it is one of those books you read which”
Dan Wang I think that James C. Scott's most popular work, Seeing Like a State, is also, unfortunately, his, I would… 2
“I think that James C. Scott's most popular work, Seeing Like a State, is also, unfortunately, his, I would say, weakest work.”
“Yeah, I was born in China's most mountainous province and I am still very much attracted to mountains in part because of the works of political scientist and anthropologist James C. Scott of Yale University. His best known work is seeing like a state in which Scott wrote about how the state really tries to organize the population in order”
Andrew (Andrewism) You know, um James C. Scott talks about this in seeing like a state. You can't just the in these states the… 1
“You know, um James C. Scott talks about this in seeing like a state. You can't just the in these states they they they start these sort of forestry projects. They they they try to legible legibleize you know these forests these simple rows”
Balaji Srinivasan in fact there's a book called seeing like a state which actually talks about the origins of surnames and wh… 1
“in fact there's a book called seeing like a state which actually talks about the origins of surnames and whatnot”
Dwarkesh Patel Beijing's urban design looks like something straight out of James Scott's Seeing Like a State. 1
“Beijing's urban design looks like something straight out of James Scott's Seeing Like a State.”
Ezra Klein You know the old book James Scott seeing like a state, right? That the state has to make things legible to… 1
“You know the old book James Scott seeing like a state, right? That the state has to make things legible to itself.”
Michael Mayer And I had read a book maybe a few years before coming up with the idea called Seeing Like a State, which is… 1
“And I had read a book maybe a few years before coming up with the idea called Seeing Like a State, which is all about how states or governments or whatever, their entire function is making legibility among their population”
Robert Breedlove so this is from the book uh seeing like a state he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible 1
“so this is from the book uh seeing like a state he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible”
“One of the main aims of the state, and this is from the book, seeing like a state, he said that the state tries to make taxpayers legible.”
Will Larson You know, the J Reed seeing like a state, like you're not allowed to be in Silicon Valley if you haven't re… 1
“You know, the J Reed seeing like a state, like you're not allowed to be in Silicon Valley if you haven't read Seeing as it like like a state, but it's basically um a book about how a state sees citizens and accomplishments and how that shapes how policy works.”
Mentioned on the show without a named speaker4
“I keep going back to um James Scott, Seeing Like a State, which is, you know, an amazing book. If people haven't read it, absolutely pick up a copy.”
“I just want to recommend this this book that Elan and mock but actually recommend it to me so I'm just totally jacking from them that I I came to love it more than they ever will it's called seeing like a state by Jim Scott”
“a thing in a sense like anything great is messy building anything great is messy and so if you look at like you know an art studio or an operating room or you know my favorite example just from seeing like the state”
“the idiosyncrasies of your situation are more relevant than you think like you can't truly describe your whole situation in like an hour or something like it's you know a lot more use and credited stuff than you think”